Tropical Fish Keeping banner

1 - 13 of 13 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
268 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I have a 25 gallon tank which inhabited a blue tang infected with ich. She is now dead with no fish left. I have a snail and hermit crab in there. I want to treat the tank without killing them so how would i do that? Is there any quick solutions without taking out the inverts?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,088 Posts
Parasites will usually die off on their own without a host... I'm reading 8 weeks for marine ich :/
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
300 Posts
Hyposalinity is done at 1.009. 1.013 will not kill of the parasite. Also, he has inverts and this will kill them as well as the live rock in the tank.

I think you're only option at this point is to let your tank sit fallow but there's a lot of differant opinions on for how long.

Also hyposalinity. Bring the sg slowly (like a week) down to 1.013 for about four weeks, then slowly back up to 1.025.
Posted via Mobile Device
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,667 Posts
Hyposalinity is done at 1.009. 1.013 will not kill of the parasite. Also, he has inverts and this will kill them as well as the live rock in the tank.
Thanks for clarifying this for me. My post was hasty and not well explained and I apologize for that.

How established is this rock in the tank? From the picture I saw in another thread, it looks to be pretty new, and not that established. There is a rock with some recently purchased coral that looks a lot more live than the rock behind it.

If the rock is not really established and there aren't a huge population of pods and other crustaceans, then taking out the hermit and the snail (and that recently acquired live rock and coral) would allow him to do a hyposalinity treatment without killing off the beneficial bacteria that might already be present in the rock.

I have always Quarantined my fish after purchase in 1.013 and slowly raised it to my tank water (1.025) in order to transfer them to the DT. I have never had an ich outbreak in my tanks and I partly attribute it to this method, but I also think that the overall health of the specimen has a lot to do with this. I prefer that fish that I buy have been at the store for a while, and my old LFS would actually hold fish for me if I was interested (he knew that if I asked, I was serious and would purchase the fish). This way I knew he was healthy and eating before I bought him.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
268 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
I Let It Sit For Three Weeks Then I Hastily Added Black Clownfish And Coral I WanteD identified In Another Thread. One Of The Fish Has White spots On His Tail. They Are Eating Fine And No Symptoms Yet. But I DoNotWant Them dyinG. I Also Have 4 Snails And A Fire Shrimp...Treatment Plans?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
300 Posts
There really aren't any treatments you can do in your display tank that won't kill your other species. LFS may try and sell you sometype of reef safe medicine but I've not read anything where there are a lot of success stories with these. 2 known things work for ich, hyopslainity and copper based meds, both of which will kill your inverts and your live rock. If you can, you should set-up a QT for the clowns and try hyposalinity. They'll have to stay in there for quite sometime though so your main tank can go through the ich cycle and die off before adding them back. Ich can lay in the substrate in the dormant stage for quite sometime. I've read varying reports of up to 6-8 weeks and on rare occassions, even longer.

I Let It Sit For Three Weeks Then I Hastily Added Black Clownfish And Coral I WanteD identified In Another Thread. One Of The Fish Has White spots On His Tail. They Are Eating Fine And No Symptoms Yet. But I DoNotWant Them dyinG. I Also Have 4 Snails And A Fire Shrimp...Treatment Plans?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
268 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
I Feed Mysis Shrimp
There really aren't any treatments you can do in your display tank that won't kill your other species. LFS may try and sell you sometype of reef safe medicine but I've not read anything where there are a lot of success stories with these. 2 known things work for ich, hyopslainity and copper based meds, both of which will kill your inverts and your live rock. If you can, you should set-up a QT for the clowns and try hyposalinity. They'll have to stay in there for quite sometime though so your main tank can go through the ich cycle and die off before adding them back. Ich can lay in the substrate in the dormant stage for quite sometime. I've read varying reports of up to 6-8 weeks and on rare occassions, even longer.

SoYouBelieve The Ich Is ForSure? No Itching Just WHite Spots
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
268 Posts
Discussion Starter #11 (Edited)
Pictures

Got quite a few



Best picture of what I usually see (other particles is because fire shrimp just pushed some stuff up off the rock)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
268 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
But it is still white spots and I had ich only 3 weeks ago so I am still scared ya know? The last two are the best quality ones
 
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
Top