Tropical Fish Keeping banner

1 - 13 of 13 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
What do you guys think? I was reading that Osmocote is generally not used in aquariums bc it can release ammonia into the water. If you have already cycled this could cause a nitrate spike. But what about using this as a food source for an aquarium that is just starting its cycle? What do you think? Could also give the plants a boost and be nice and lush when its time to add the fishies.

Please let me know your thoughts i would love to hear them as i have a 20 gal tall thats less than 24 hours in to fishless cycle.

THANKS!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,183 Posts
I'm pretty sure Scott's Osmocote is an inorganic lawn and plant food that does not belong in an aquarium.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
i don't have scotts. I have a DIY one that a local guy did for aquariums and there is info of it being used regularly in aquariums. I just wanted to know what people thought about using it as the ammonia source as i am not sure how much ammonia it releases. The only thing i have read on that topic is "It releases 50% of its ammonia in the first 72 hours" and that was a guys opinion, not facts.

what i have is a little pill like capsule with about 30-40 little spheres in it. It is supposed to be a time released fert.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,183 Posts
'Osmocote' is a trade marked product marketed by Scott's as a lawn / plant food so I'm not sure what you have.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,010 Posts
What do you guys think? I was reading that Osmocote is generally not used in aquariums bc it can release ammonia into the water. If you have already cycled this could cause a nitrate spike. But what about using this as a food source for an aquarium that is just starting its cycle? What do you think? Could also give the plants a boost and be nice and lush when its time to add the fishies.

Please let me know your thoughts i would love to hear them as i have a 20 gal tall thats less than 24 hours in to fishless cycle.

THANKS!
If you have plants, enough plants, you don't need to cycle, add the fish and they will provide a CO2 and ammonia boost helping the plants while the plants help the fish.

As far as a solid fertilizer of whatever source, I don't think it's a great idea. They are meant to be rained on not immersed. I might expect that if they dissolve the ammonia "boost" would be, at best, unpredictable, at worst, enough to kill your plants.

Is that the 20 gallon in the profile?

What fish, how many and how large are they?

Jeff.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,059 Posts
i don't have scotts. I have a DIY one that a local guy did for aquariums and there is info of it being used regularly in aquariums. I just wanted to know what people thought about using it as the ammonia source as i am not sure how much ammonia it releases. The only thing i have read on that topic is "It releases 50% of its ammonia in the first 72 hours" and that was a guys opinion, not facts.

what i have is a little pill like capsule with about 30-40 little spheres in it. It is supposed to be a time released fert.
Sounds like your talking about DIY root tabs that are Osmocote+ in a size 00 gel capsule. Many people do use them and I have myself. I wouldn't however use it to start a cycle. I don't know if that ammonia release figure is true or not. I can't recall ever seeing a spike, but then I don't use tons of capsules at once.

Just for arguments sake let's say it does release ammonia in the way that guy said. You would likely have to use a bunch of it which also means way too many ferts. That would of course lead to an algae farm even if it did start a cycle.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,010 Posts
I should clarify when I said "solid fertilizer of whatever source", what I meant was other than setting up your own macros or solids for aquarium use specifically as opposed to lawn care products. Way past editing time for this.

Jeff.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
178 Posts
I've been looking into Osmocote recently as I've been wanting to make my own ferts at home.


If you crush up the spheres, it'll release a ton of ammonia at once, but youd still need a lot of them and I dont think it would be beneficial to the plants since you cant really control how much ammonia will be released. Youre likely to not release enough to properly cycle or too much and burn your plants.

Osmocote+ also has a bunch of trace elements in it which may or may not have an adverse affect on the aquarium depending on how much you use of it.


If you leave them as is and use it as ferts under the substrate, I dont think it will release enough, plus the plants will more than likely just suck it up before its released into the water.




I think your better off just running a cycle with one of the tried and true methods.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
22,557 Posts
I have never cycled an aquarium in over 20 years. As Jeff said, you plant it and that takes care of the "cycle." Floating plants and faster-growing plants work best as they use (take up) more ammonia. A few fish with the plants, and you're done.

Byron.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,224 Posts
Just for arguments sake let's say it does release ammonia in the way that guy said. You would likely have to use a bunch of it which also means way too many ferts. That would of course lead to an algae farm even if it did start a cycle.
took thw words right out of my mouth
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
thanks for th einput guys. based on your input i think i am just gonna pass on the osmocote idea. I may add fish but not until i have more plants. i am planting in sections to me sure i like my scape. The right side is set now the left side i want a lot more and kind of an opening in the center.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,010 Posts
thanks for th einput guys. based on your input i think i am just gonna pass on the osmocote idea. I may add fish but not until i have more plants. i am planting in sections to me sure i like my scape. The right side is set now the left side i want a lot more and kind of an opening in the center.
Great plan. Just add fish one species at a time or in small groups. Even the plants need some time to adjust to a new ammonia and CO2 level and the tank can give you a nitrite spike as well.

Keep in mind that plants will look different as they mature, height, width, leaf size etc. I'm finding that what I thought would look good initially has changed. I started out with lots of varieties and still have to decide on placement as things grow.

Keep us updated.... with pics too.

Jeff.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
if you check my aquarium log, the 20 is the one i am setting up now, you can see where it is. Its been up for just over 24 hours at this point.
 
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
Top