MH Vs LED's Vs T5
Tropical Fish

Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources » Saltwater Fish and Coral Reef Tanks » Beginner Saltwater Aquariums » Saltwater Aquarium Equipment » MH Vs LED's Vs T5

MH Vs LED's Vs T5

This is a discussion on MH Vs LED's Vs T5 within the Saltwater Aquarium Equipment forums, part of the Beginner Saltwater Aquariums category; --> Which is the best for corals? Which gives the best visual effect?> And any other comparisons welcome, ESPICIALLY personal experiences. Also which brands have ...

Check out these saltwater fish profiles
Sailfin Tang
Sailfin Tang
Bicolor Angelfish
Bicolor Angelfish
View Poll Results: Which is better?
Metal Halide 1 50.00%
LED's (par, kessils, etc) 1 50.00%
T5 fixtures 0 0%
Voters: 2. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
Old 06-07-2013, 10:03 AM   #1
 
killavixen's Avatar
 
MH Vs LED's Vs T5

Which is the best for corals?
Which gives the best visual effect?>
And any other comparisons welcome, ESPICIALLY personal experiences.
Also which brands have you used?
killavixen is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-07-2013, 01:24 PM   #2
 
wake49's Avatar
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by killavixen View Post
Which is the best for corals?
Which gives the best visual effect?>
And any other comparisons welcome, ESPICIALLY personal experiences.
Also which brands have you used?
I have used and had success with all three. I didn't like the bulb replacement with T5HO being every six months and costing me $200+ (I had a 12-bulb fixture over my 150). I didn't like the energy consumption and heat transfer of Metal Halides. My corals looked amazing under MH. Amazing. The light is so crisp that it really makes everything look surreal.

CurrentUSA was the brand of the T5HO fixture I used. Good fixture, I would buy it again if I were going that route. For the Metal Halide, I do not know the name brand. I think that most of these are going to be the same anyway. I had external ballasts on that one and it was just a pain in the butt when all was said and done...

Right now I use a Green Element EVO LED fisxture. It is over my 20 and can be a little spotlighty, but I don't really care. I think it does the job because I have coraline algae blossoming and no real green algae *knocks on wood* on the rocks. If you can get past the lack of diffusers on the Green Element fixture, it is not really that bad for the money. I would probably go a different route if I did it all over...
wake49 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-07-2013, 03:54 PM   #3
 
killavixen's Avatar
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by wake49 View Post
I have used and had success with all three. I didn't like the bulb replacement with T5HO being every six months and costing me $200+ (I had a 12-bulb fixture over my 150). I didn't like the energy consumption and heat transfer of Metal Halides. My corals looked amazing under MH. Amazing. The light is so crisp that it really makes everything look surreal.

CurrentUSA was the brand of the T5HO fixture I used. Good fixture, I would buy it again if I were going that route. For the Metal Halide, I do not know the name brand. I think that most of these are going to be the same anyway. I had external ballasts on that one and it was just a pain in the butt when all was said and done...

Right now I use a Green Element EVO LED fisxture. It is over my 20 and can be a little spotlighty, but I don't really care. I think it does the job because I have coraline algae blossoming and no real green algae *knocks on wood* on the rocks. If you can get past the lack of diffusers on the Green Element fixture, it is not really that bad for the money. I would probably go a different route if I did it all over...
I love how you always comment on my posts :) And thanks for the insight
killavixen is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-08-2013, 01:15 AM   #4
 
badxgillen's Avatar
 
Whats the BEST lighting is not really a question easily answered as it can be rather opinion based. Seeing as most of it is hear say,many people dont have experience in multiple fixtures.There really is no wrong way as long as the PAR reading are there and it leads to happy corals.I run all types of bulbs over my reef tanks from T-12s,T-5HO,Halide moguls & HQI, Power Compacts,and a number of LED units including marineland,Kessel,Evergrow,Reefstar, and DIY. All of them are growing many corals rather well. I can say you cannot get the same punch or visual effect from all of the lights but each one serves its purpose.For instance I have 1 metal halide mogul 250 watt over a 40 breeder and it is stacked with corals SPS,LPS,and then some but if I put a evergrow or the standard 55 3 watt cree LED fixture you need 2 to cover the area.If you do the math the LEDs are actual taking more power.Also on bulb exchanges it depends on the degredation of the bulb.Many of my T-5s and Halide moguls have retained there PAR ratings even after a year.I also dont find the bulbs to be too costly seeing as they cost from $11-$20 either T-5 HO or 250 watt halide"HQI is another story".Also if the depth of the tank is shallow I have some tanks with a shop light and good bulbs that rock some mad corals.You could argue heat into the equation but once again that is relevant to the setup and if it does not have sufficient heat exchange or if you live some where that the heat is negligible like me. So many pros and cons.

My point being BEST is a term hard to place on a light.Now as far as aesthetics its hard to beat a 2 channel LED that has UV lightin with its 460 Nanometer blue lights.I have boughten corals I already had because under the super UV actinic it looked UNREAL.I agree with wake that a metal halide is hard to beat as far as naturaly sureal looking goes...but they are now making LEDs to replicate the look of a halide.Sorry for the long post its just a hard question to answer.
badxgillen is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-08-2013, 01:26 AM   #5
 
badxgillen's Avatar
 
Upon thinking about it it might be possible to answer the question of better lighting options if you gave information on what you are lighting and keeping?I know a halide may be nice but over a nano is not so nice.T-5HOs are nice but not over hexes...unless its all softies and LPS. And LEDs are good too but cost a bit and dont have the spread unless you can modify the optics...if there are any on the unit.
badxgillen is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Marineland Aquatic Plant Lighting LED system vs their Doublebright LED JDM Freshwater Aquarium Equipment 1 04-19-2013 06:38 PM
LED lighting? SinCrisis Off Topic Discussions 2 04-16-2011 01:12 PM


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:08 AM.