Ok...so I am about to be getting a 30 or 33 gallon tank and stand. I want to try planting this tankl. My mother in law has a goldfish in a 5 gallon and I want to give her my 10 gallon that I am currently using. She only has an internal pump/filter and that is not going to be enough for the 10 gallon. Before I thought about giving her my 10 gallon I was going to use the current filter on it to use in the 30/33. It is a Penguin 100B so I know I would need to add to it anyway.
Here is my dilemma...
- do I just get a bigger filter (or two smaller ones?) for my 30/33 and add plants and not worry about another cycle and give her my current filter?
-Do I give her the filter and just get an appropriate size sponge filter/air pump (can someone point me to a good one)? Again adding plants to not worry about the cycling again.
- Buy her an appropriate filter and let her use the media in her current filter (if there is any) and gravel to seed the 10 while keeping my filter and adding a second to get the appropriate filtration in my tank?
Okay, I think that is all for now. Please let me now if there is something I am missing.
O...I plan on keeping some/most of my current gravel to seed my new tank as well.
You still need to cycle even if your adding plants.. If you want to quick cycle, run your current filter with the old media in the new tank along with your new filter. I'd recommend an AquaClear 50. If you don't plan on having a quarantine or hospital tank then I'd give her your filter once your done with it.
That much flow wouldnt be too much for the plants/fish? The fish in my sig will be moved to this tank and add more.
And as luck would have it, her goldfish died today. So I will hang on to all my equipment to seed the new tank. Will be going from natural gravel to play sand.
What are everyones thoughts on sponge filters? Thanks again everyone!
Not to much flow, the AquaClears have an adjustable flow as well, but I've run a AC50 on a 10g before, on my 29 gallon I'm currently running an AC50 and an AC20 both running at full blast with 2 platys, some neons and guppies. Always better to have to much filtration then not enough and running a filter meant for 30 gallons on a 30g tank barely cuts it.
Sponge filters are good I've never run them in anything bigger then a 10g though, I use them mostly for fry tanks and shrimp tanks.
I run sand in all my tanks as well, be sure when your working on the bottom to shut off your filters don't want any strired up sand getting sucked into them.
First, welcome to Tropical Fish Keeping forum. Glad to have you join us.
A good sponge filter will be sufficient for a 30g (I have an Elite dual sponge on my 29g), especially with live plants [good idea:-D]. The Elite duals are good, or the Hydro spong rated for a 30g. Playsand is a good substrate, I now have it in 3 tanks. You only want about 2 inches depth across the tank.
Thanks Byron. What would be a good air pump/powerhead to use for the Elite duals? And where did you get yours? I saw some on drsfostersmith that look similar to the one you have posted before but wasnt sure if it was the Elite or not. Thanks for the help and welcoming.
Elite dual sponges are what I have in my 20g and 29g tanks. Photo below. There is also the Hydro, I have one of these in a 10g. Both in my view are very good filters.
Would a single Elite double sponge be okay for a 4' 33long? Also, do you think an AquaClear 70 would create too much flow? I can get one for a good price.
The AC's have adjustable flow, I've run a 110 on my 40 breeder, even on full flow as long as I kept the water level all the way up the current from it wasn't bad, maybe to much for a betta but ok for most all fish.
You're intending live plants, so I would stay with a sponge filter. And for a 3-foot a dual Elite will be fine. Another option is an internal filter that is basically a motor and sponge, Fluval I belive make these. This is useful if noise is an issue, as they are quieter than most air pumps which you need for the Elite or Hydro.
I am not a fan of HOB filters in planted tanks. And I have used them, back in the 1980's. No longer my choice.
|All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:48 PM.|
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.