Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources

Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources (
-   Freshwater and Tropical Fish (
-   -   Are there any fry-safe Algae Eaters, other than Otos & Snails? (

Akeath 07-07-2011 02:13 PM

Are there any fry-safe Algae Eaters, other than Otos & Snails?
I have a brown algae problem in my aquarium, due to my tap water - no matter how well I keep up with water changes, how much I make sure to not overfeed, how well I gravel vacuum, or how I mess with the lights its been like that ever since my tap water company decided to change to chloramine disinfection, which produces some ammonia as a byproduct. I'm able to keep the fish from being harmed by the Ammonia by using Prime as my dechlorinator, but it still causes algae blooms. Since I have a 75 gallon aquarium, buying RO water from the store isn't a good solution either, and RO units would be very expensive and produce too much waste water for me to want to invest in one.

So that leaves me with an algae eater. I have Panda Cory fry in this tank pretty constantly, and I'm very fond of them all and want to make sure they'd be safe with any algae eater I've got. All of the fish in this aquarium are small, too, ranging from an adult size of 1 inch to 2.5 inches.

I've tried Otos, and have had horrible luck with them in my tank. They've all died. My pH is too acidic for snails to live in there comfortably in this tank, too.

Is there any other algae eater that would eat brown algae, but would be safe around the Panda Cory fry that are often born in this aquarium, as well as safe for the other small fish?

ladayen 07-07-2011 02:58 PM

Well... I've been researching plants lately and it seems to be the best way to get rid of algae.. is to have plants, or more of them.

Algae is just another plant(for the most part, some are large amounts of bacteria.) To get of an unwanted species you introduce either predators(like algae eaters) or food competition( like plants).

Plants have the dual benefit of providing hiding places for the fry, some may even provide food.

Akeath 07-07-2011 05:38 PM

Some of the chemicals I regularly use in this tank aren't usable with plants in. I do use the plant strategy to keep the algae down in my 10 gallon, and it works fairly well, though I still have to algae scrape a bit every week. And I have an Olive Nerite in my 5 gallon who keeps it completely free of algae, but that is my high pH tank. Besides the chemical thing, though, I just don't want to have plants in the 75 gallon. I like easily rearranging it, I spent months choosing each decoration and how it would work with each fish species, and I'm already catering to the needs of a fish community, so I don't want to balance in lots of variety of plants needs too. If I could get one more fish species, I feel more up to that than changing the whole tank to planted (my parameters would be good for most catfish like plecos already, for example), and with the amount of algae in there I think just a couple plants wouldn't cut it.

ladayen 07-07-2011 06:41 PM

Ahh I see.. ok well I'll give you this link I found and let you do your research :) Seems your pretty capable of that.

Aquarium Algae Eaters

Byron 07-07-2011 07:29 PM

I'm not certain ammonia (from chloramine) is the problem. Diatoms occur from silicates (a mineral) and/or low light. If the light is the problem, that is easily remedied, even simply by light plus floating plants wich consume high nutrients (would help with the ammonia/chloramine too). If silicates, then diluting the water is the best option.

The use of chemicals that are not safe for plants especially with cory fry sound dangerous. These are sensitive fish when developing, as most fish are actually. In my view nothing but a water conditioner should go in their water. Any chemical that would harm a plant is likely to be detrimental to fry and even mature fish.


Akeath 07-07-2011 11:09 PM

I've experimented with this algae problem a bit, and I don't think it is light related. The diatoms have been very bad in all three of my aquariums. In my 5 and 10 gallon, I experimented with light (because its cheaper to do that with smaller tanks compared to a 75 gallon). I've done from 2 watts per gallon to 5 watts per gallon seeing how it would effect the diatoms - and the higher the light, the worse the diatoms get. They were much much worse in the 2 watt per gallon than in the 75 gallon that has 1/2 watt per gallon. In the 5 watts per gallon, they were incredibly bad. I'd hoped to change them to green algae by the higher lighting (because I think green algae can be kind've pretty), but it just remained diatoms and become more prevalent. Also, in the wall panel of the 75 gallon that is very close to the 10 gallon (which has brighter light) I have more diatoms than anywhere else in the 75 gallon.
I also experimented a lot with plants in the 10 gallon before making any headway at all with the diatom problem. I used Wisteria, which as I understand consumes nutrients pretty well, and it didn't make much difference by itself. The diatoms were growing on the leaves, I had to keep cleaning them off. Eventually I got a light-fertilizer-plant amount balance that keeps the algae in there tolerable, but not ideal. I also have some Cherry Shrimp in there as well, which will nibble on algae, but don't make much difference at all.

The thing with the 75 gallon and diluting is, that's a pretty big volume of water, and it would be expensive to either buy RO water to dilute it or get an RO unit, as I do 40% water changes a week and its a big tank to begin with. I pay for the things my fish need healthwise and to take care of them, but something that just looks bad in the aquarium to me I would rather take care of by cheaper means, if possible, I don't have an endless supply of money. And I wouldn't mind having an excuse to get a new fish, either.

As for the chemical, Proper pH 7.0, it does not actually harm plants. The reason the instructions give for not using it with plants is that it is a "phosphate buffer" and plants will consume some of the phosphate and cause the pH to swing. It has occurred to me that the phosphate from this pH adjustor is causing my algal bloom. However, I only use it in 1 of my 3 tanks and all 3 tanks had the problem at the same level, and I was using it for months without it causing this issue (the months I had the tank set up before the water changed). Also, my boyfriend who lives just over the state border (different water company) also uses this chemical in his tanks and has never had diatoms in his aquariums. I know a lot of people don't like adjusting the pH with chemicals, but my pH is very high out of the tap (8.2-8.4), and I have been using this chemical for 2 years during which the pH has never swung and it has kept it in the ideal levels for my fish. I've tested it many times during different days of the week and different months of the year to make sure it stays the same, and it always has. I've researched it in regard to Cories as well and have found no reports of it causing any issues with them, and I've never observed any abnormalities in my Cory fry from babyhood to full growth in this tank. My mother used this in a guppy breeding tank for about 10 years too, and there were never any abnormalities in those fry either, so I believe it is safe.
I don't know why the diatoms don't cause it to swing, though, if they consume phosphates too...but for some reason they don't. Never thought about that. Well, its good they don't. Nevertheless, I would not like to push my luck with adding plants when it says in the instructions not to. And I don't really want to change my method of acidifying the water either, because using this chemical has been more precise for me than using peat and bogwood, which I've used in the other aquariums so that I could have plants in them.

I guess I just assumed the Ammonia in the tap was causing it because I'd never had any diatom issues before until the tap water company started adding chloramine in. I was experiencing issues with the algae and elevated Ammonia levels. I was losing some Panda Cories because of the Ammonia levels. I was very confused because I had made no changes to anything. I'd called the tap water company and asked for changes in the water, and the chloramine and Ammonia were the only ones they mentioned. However, I had to call a few times before I got answers on it, and I wouldn't be surprised if there is something else like Silica that they changed at the same time and just forgot to mention. I was sooo mad they didn't notify me ahead of time about that Ammonia, so I have a tendency to vilify it - if I hadn't tested the tap water and started using Prime I'm sure all of my Pandas would've died, I'd lost a few before I found out the problem.

I have an adorable Olive Nerite Snail named Callahan in my 5 gallon, and he has taken care of the algae completely in that tank. There is no sign of it anywhere. (And, he produces enough poop that I don't need to fertilize the plants in there! He's a double-worker :lol:). I've tried light changes, I've tried plant changes, and for a while I tried DO water in my 10 gallon (that did help, but again, it would be expensive in the 75) but none of those have worked as well as my little algae eater. And I thought it would be worth a try in the 75 gallon to find something that was compatible with everyone. I'd get another snail, but the water in there is, in my opinion, too acidic for a snail. I think he would have shell erosion, and I don't want that to happen. I also have misgivings about trusting my Praecox Rainbows with something like Amano Shrimp. And I know Otos are safe with fry, but I've had trouble getting them to survive in my tank - they don't acclimate into it well, I lost a whole school of them I added over a week or so and I don't want to try again if it means they may just die, I don't want to risk their lives. I understand that getting a fish to fix your problem isn't ideal, but I'm at the end of my rope with this algae, its just so darn stubborn. I spent an hour cleaning my 75 gallon decorations and tank glass of it today, I do that almost every week, it just keeps coming back and there's so much of it. I've looked into algae eaters a lot too, but most articles on it don't mention if they are safe with little fry. The best I've been able to find is a list of fish they are compatible with. I'm also having trouble finding this info on a forum search. That's why I've asked.

Byron 07-08-2011 02:03 PM

Here's a link to some fairly detailed info on diatoms:
Brown Diatom Algae Control | Aquariums Life

Another thing about mixing water is that it would solve your pH problem and you would not need to spend money on that stuff. Depending upon where you live, rainwater could be used. Also boiled water, boiling removes minerals thus softening the water. Once the tank was biologically settled with a lower hardness/pH, it would naturally tend to remain there. Partial water changes could be minimal.

Otos and Farlowella vittata will both handle diatoms, but both also need soft water. That may be the problem with otos for you. They are wild caught.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:05 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2