Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources

Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources (
-   Cyprinids and Atherinids (
-   -   Should gold fish be kept in a species only tank? (

Grimmjow 01-12-2010 07:47 AM

Should gold fish be kept in a species only tank?
So my girlfriends sister got a 1 gallon tank and put 4 goldfish in it, stupid i know. But my girlfriend took them and put them in the bigger tank she has which i think is a 20 or 30 or something like that. For some reason i think they should be kept in a species only tank, should they? or are they fine in a community tank?

I know next to nothing about gold fish, how big of a tank would they need and all that. Pretty sure they are just the normal ones. I have a 15g in my garage, and if the tank they ar ein or the 15 is too small i have a pond in my backyard that has a couple there already.

JohnnyD44 01-12-2010 08:35 AM

Well, first things depend on the type of goldfish it is....most goldfish, usually the cheapest ones that are for sell in bulk at stores are used a feeder fish for bigger fish....these fish are usually disease ridden and shouldn't be kept as normal goldfish, especially with other fish, i wouldn't take the chance of harming the other inhabitants....

If they are a different kind of goldish (fancy, etc...) these fish need alot of room. Not so much room as they do filtration, which usually comes with the bigger tank....goldfish are some of the messiest fish around....I've read that some breeds have no stomach, just a digestive tract....they eat and it comes right out, so to speak.....for 4 goldfish, assuming they are not feeder fish, depending on the type, I wouldn't keep them in anything smaller than a 40G tank....but like I said, it all depends on the breed, but a majority of non-feeder-fish need alot of filtration to keep up with the amount of waste they produce....

Jill0 01-12-2010 08:43 AM

Goldfish should really have about 10g each, and frequent large water changes... I have kept zebra danios successfully with goldfish, but you need to be sure there's enough water.

iamntbatman 01-12-2010 04:49 PM

They're pretty friendly and sociable fish so they can be kept with other coldwater fish like weather loaches without problems. They do need large tanks and plenty of filtration though. Even for the smaller fancy varieties, I would say a 30g tank is too small for four fish. She should look into something like a 75g for four goldfish.

Lupin 01-13-2010 01:11 AM

Brace yourself for the info getting a tad long.:lol:


Aquarium Size, Variants of Goldfish and General Guidelines
A. Impracticality of “Traditional” Fishbowls and Aquarium Size Guidelines for Fancy and Pond Goldfish

In China, for several centuries, it has been their tradition to place goldfish in their fishbowls. This trend continues until today and will continue so despite the attempted passing of the bill by several countries particularly in Europe to ban the use of fishbowls towards goldfish due to the number of incidence where goldfish die within a few days or even weeks as a result of ignorance shared by a lot of people who buy fish without doing their homework first. To understand better why the fishbowls became part of the Chinese tradition, in China, their ardor usually is not spacious thus large aquaria are not an option for them to keep their fish in. Round smooth bowls were designed with great effect including the fish in them that they become part of the ambiance. China is a temperate zone. Unlike the tropical areas, in temperate areas, goldfish do not eat a lot due to the low temperature wherein their metabolic rate decreases significantly and in turn, reducing the pollution.

Nowadays, a lot of hobbyists have access to larger house and lots and modern technology thus improving the life support systems further. They are able to accommodate large aquarium systems which benefit the goldfish greatly. Aquarium size is a very important factor that must be carefully planned as it greatly influences the potential of the fish to reach its adult size. Aside from that, this helps the fish utilize their excess carbohydrates that they accumulate from consuming foods containing excess carbohydrates. If you have heard the saying, “the solution to pollution is dilution”, the saying is indeed very true.

Goldfish are no stranger to severely deteriorating water conditions however like all other fish, they become prone to several health issues as a result of the poor water conditions. Unfortunately for the fish, they produce a heavy amount of urea and feces especially when their metabolic rate is increased due to the elevated temperature. As a result, the water quality deteriorates rather rapidly especially when the tank is rather less than ideal in size.

Considering goldfish themselves do not stay small (which is why fishbowls are impractical nowadays) at 8 to 24 inches range, a general guideline for fancy types should be at least fifteen gallons per fish whereas pond types need at least twenty gallons per fish. Previous debates have been offered that the fancy types need a minimum of at least ten gallons per fish. While this point of argument does prove itself feasible, giving more allowance for space would be a much better option for the goldfish.

The above paragraph does not mean you can freely utilize the spare fifteen and twenty gallon tanks for goldfish. Those tanks are still very limited and you cannot keep goldfish in isolation as these are sociable by nature and unlikely to thrive for a long time if deprived of their company. With the number of goldfish suggested at three as the possible minimum, a 55g would be a best starting point for fancy goldfish whereas 75g would be the minimum for at least two to three pond types.

B. Variants of Goldfish

As the goldfish has been bred for decades, many strains have been formed as a result of selective breeding. This in itself complicates matters further as the different body formation of the fish also requires a few perks in how you attempt to accommodate them to avoid any future issues that will prove detrimental to their health.

For instance, bubble eyes are famous for their large bulbous eye sacs that dangle below their eyes. The eye sacs are quite delicate and easily punctured hence you have to avoid sharp edged decorations if you want to keep their eye sacs intact. Although the eye sacs will normally heal themselves, the injured sac will usually look very different than the previous. A lot of round bodied types are prone to buoyancy problems due to the compressed organs brought about by their distended abdomen. There are many causes to buoyancy disorders which we can cover later on as we go further into this.

Fancy Types
Doubletail with dorsal fins
Black Moor/Demekin/Telescope/Globe Eye
Tikus Pearlscale
Crown Pearlscale

Doubletail without dorsal fins
Bubble Eyes

Pond Types
Singletail with streamlined body
Common Goldfish/Hibuna

Singletail with rounded body


C. Stunting Explained

Stunting is one of the most controversial subjects in the history of aquarium trade. Until now, it remains a debate with various theories given as to what causes the fish to stunt. This complication is brought by the fact that there are differnt variables that influence greatly the growth rate of the fish.

Stress is the number one factor that is quite overlooked when it comes to stunting issues being addressed. When a fish becomes stressed, it releases the hormones, norepinephrine and epinephrine in response to stress, both of which reduce the growth hormones greatly. Once the stressor has been removed, the fish may gain a growth spurt due to the rebound effect by releasing more growth hormones. For further scientific studies, the abstract can be found here. Another abstract describing further what stress is, can be found here.

Stress occurs because of various factors. One such factor to address is overcrowding. This is a very commonly done mistake in the aquarium hobby. Many people have the tendency to buy a lot of fish on impulse and forget that their fish are still on growing stage. In overcrowded tanks, fish cannot feel comfortable or secured because of constant activities which eventually stresses them and makes them more vulnerable to health issues. The lack of space prevents the fish from developing normally as they should have. Overcrowding also encourages the proliferation of parasites whether fatal or not thus the fish are extremely stressed by the constant infestations and secondary infections.

JohnnyD44 01-16-2010 10:26 PM

very nice Lupin....thats why your king of goldfish!!!

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:04 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome