Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources

Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources (
-   Characins (
-   -   Pencilfish (

fishyinpa 08-10-2009 03:46 PM

So,I am jumping all around this forum lol. Anyways,I was looking up Pencilfish (many kinds of them) and I really like them. I kinda like them more then Harlies. Its only the matter of what I can find around here. Is there a specific Pencilfish I should look for? Or is any one okay really...I have a 12 gallon tank with 7 (possibly 8,new baby I spotted) panda Corys. Byron suggested I add some top level swimmers. :-)

fishyinpa 08-10-2009 07:26 PM

Well my sister called an aquarium place down in the city,they dont have them in now but can be ordered. I tried my lfs but they arent too good with ordering fish for you. So I guess wait and see if this one gets them in. Hope someone gets back to me on here,so I know if they are good fish or not lol.

Byron 08-11-2009 10:31 AM

I've maintained pencilfish for many years, but they are not always easy to get as you're finding out. Don't know why, they are wonderful little tetra-like fish and very colourful.

There are several species, found in two genera as established by Gery, Nannobrycon and Nannostomus; you may still see a reference now and then to Poecilobrycon, but Gery determined that this is probably a subspecies of Nannostomus. There are two known species in Nannobrycon, and several in Nannostomus. In all cases, these fish are shoaling characins and must be kept in a group of minimum 5 or 6, more if space permits. The males will challenge one another regularly, but seldom cause any damage; but for a small fish, they are quite feisty at times. Some species have an adipose fin (a characteristic of many characins) while other species do not, and occasionally fish within the same species may or may not have this fin. All species have distinctive diurnal colour patters, meaning that they look quite different during darkness than during the day. Those species posessing lateral strips (all but one, Nannostomus espei, have this pattern) lose the stripes at night and have broken blotches along the sides, and different colouration. Gery suggested that the Nannostomus genus is still actively evolving, and there are indications that the species in this genus exist in "pairs" that are indistinguishable externally, and this may explain why fish within some of the species can be somewhat variable (e.g., the presence or absence of the adipose fin in the same species). The "pair" species are allopatric, meaning they live in different localities and not together.

The two species in Nannobrycon, N. eques and N. unifasciatus, are easy to distinguish from the others because they both swim in a oblique manner (head up at about a 45-degree angle). The species in Nannostomus swim normally (horizontally) and are the more colourful.

The most common species is Nannostomus beckfordi, and it is the hardiest of the family and the largest in size though only 6 cm (2.2 inches) maximum; it is well able to take care of itself in any community tank that does not have aggressive fish. It mixes well with most of the other characins (tetras and hatchetfish), catfish (corys, farlowella, whiptails, small species plecos), dwarf cichlids (an ideal dither fish), etc. The sexes are easily distinguished except in young fish; males are considerably more darker, a beautiful reddish brown, and very bright red on the fins with ice blue tips on the ventral fin pair. The males almost constantly challenge each other, sometimes three in a line, side by side, darkening to almost black, but nothing rough ever comes of this; much like the male Black Phantom tetras, and some of the other Hyphessobrycon species. And N. beckfordi will spawn very readily and frequently. The only negative is that the males will drive the females very hard, which is common to many of the characins actually, and sometimes the female will die as a result. It is therefore better to have a ratio of more females to males with this species, and other pencilfish for that matter. That allows the males to divide their attention at spawning times. I have this species spawning regularly in my 115g aquarium, although the eggs are gobbled up by the other fish as soon as they are expelled.

The remaining species in Nannostomus are a bit less rambunctious and are much the same in terms of care and behaviour. N. beckfordi is now farmed commercially, so most fish in stores will be tank raised. The other species are largely wild caught, which means you have to pay closer attention to water parameters. They all come from very soft and acidic water. N. marginatus, the dwarf pencilfish, occurs throughout the Rio Negro system, found in company with cardinal tetras, hatchetfish (Carnegiella marthae and C. strigata fasciata) and many other species of shoaling tetras. The coral red pencilfish, discovered during the last decade and thought initially to be a colour variant of N. marginatus [along the lines of the "pairs' I mentioned above], was established as a separate species, N. mortenthaleri, in 2001 by Paepke & Arendt. This fish is found in streams of the Rio Nanay in Peru, the country home of your panda cory, although not in the same watercourses. Another very closely related fish, also originally thought to be a variant of N. marginatus, was described by Zarske a couple of months ago as a new species, N. rubrocaudatus, an incredibly beautiful purple variation of the two afore-mentioned species.

The other species are less often encounterd in the hobby, unfortunately; they are fascinating fish to my thinking, and easy to maintain provided water quality is good and constant.

FishinPole has a group of N. mortenthaleri and may have further insights; I only acquired mine last month.

fishyinpa 08-11-2009 11:49 AM

Wow very informative thank you so much Byron. I am not sure what kind I will find,if any.

Byron 08-11-2009 12:13 PM


Originally Posted by fishyinpa (Post 225645)
Wow very informative thank you so much Byron. I am not sure what kind I will find,if any.

You're in PA I'm assuming, as is FishinPole. I'm going from memory but I think he got his by mail online, but there is a good lfs he deals with nearby. Send him a PM, I know he'd be glad to assist with info.


P.S. Just noticed with all that blurb, forgot to mention that pencils are quite easy to feed. Even the wild caught fish take to prepared food (flake) and frozen bloodworms and daphnia almost immediately, at least my N. mortenthaleri have; they came direct from the river in Peru (through a local private importer, not a store) and considering that after the ordeal of capture, transport and coping with differing water parameters short-term they were doing well in my aquarium some two weeks or less after leaving their native water, I'm pretty happy.

fishyinpa 08-11-2009 12:23 PM

Yes,Pa here. Sounds good!
Oh yeah,thats good to know. I hope to find some,they sound so interesting.

Fishin Pole 08-11-2009 01:01 PM

If your anywhere close to Lancaster, "That Fish Place" had some nice red coral pencilfish and banded pencilfish last week.............A little high on price, but they are tought to find sometimes, but visually to me, they are worth it!

fishyinpa 08-11-2009 01:09 PM

Oh,cool! Thats a few hours from me,but they look worth it too haha. There is a place down in the city(philly) who might get them in next week..I think Ill wait and see if they get them,if not Ill check out thatpetplace er fishplace..haha..thanks again.

I just looked on that site,they have none right now. Maybe later on they will lol.

fishyinpa 08-11-2009 06:42 PM

One more question,for now anyways. What kind of current do they prefer? In my pandas tank it has a moderately strong current,which they love.

Byron 08-11-2009 07:33 PM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by fishyinpa (Post 225867)
One more question,for now anyways. What kind of current do they prefer? In my pandas tank it has a moderately strong current,which they love.

Pencilfish are found in fairly quiet water, inhabiting the shallows along streams where there are plants, roots and overhanging branches reaching into the water. A flooded forest idea suits them. Something like my (former) 70g in the photos that I moved into the 90g a couple of weeks ago (attached photo). My trio of pandas happen to be in this tank as well as the three species Nannobrycon eques, N. unifasciatus and Nannostomus mortenthaleri. The beckfordi's are in the 115g now.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:15 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome