Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources

Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources (http://www.tropicalfishkeeping.com/)
-   Cichlids (http://www.tropicalfishkeeping.com/cichlids/)
-   -   20 gallon long bolivian ram tank? (http://www.tropicalfishkeeping.com/cichlids/20-gallon-long-bolivian-ram-tank-111391/)

allaboutfish 08-20-2012 09:51 PM

20 gallon long bolivian ram tank?
 
i was wondering how many bolivian rams i can do with
9- cherry barbs
3-ottos?

allaboutfish 08-20-2012 10:14 PM

oh and a pair of endlers

fryup 08-21-2012 01:48 AM

what size tank is it cichlids need to be able to claim a territory.......... An adult ram will eat your endlers. ... If the tanks of a nice size then get a pair hope this helped :):):)
Posted via Mobile Device

allaboutfish 08-21-2012 06:37 AM

20 long, read the title. are you sure an adult endler would get eatin? ive heard that they do good together.

Chesh 08-21-2012 08:18 AM

In my personal experience, it is very unlikely that a Bolivian Ram would eat an Endler, unless it was a fry - but the two DO require very different water parameters, and shouldn't be kept together.

As far as stocking. . . with Bolivian Rams this is a bit tricky. Many people prefer to keep them alone - one in a tank, as they can get aggressive toward each-other. You have enough room to keep a pair, but with the Bolivians, just putting a male and a female in the tank will very likely end in disaster. They need to 'choose' their own mates, and if a potential partner is rejected, it will end badly. Most people prefer to get six or so juvies, and re-home the others once a pair forms up - but for obvious reasons this can be difficult! Many people feel that they do best in a shoal of 5-6+ but I'm not sure if you'd have room to keep so many in a tank that size. . .

Whichever way you go, make sure that your water is soft, and the tank well-established and planted. These fish do not do well in new setups, and are very sensitive to shifts in water parameters - and are also very sensitive to shifts in nitrate, from my experience.

Whatever you decide, if you choose more than one, be sure that you have a backup tank or a new home ready to go for the others, just in case you run into any aggression issues - every fish and every tank is unique, and it's hard to predict how things will come out. . .

hope this helped!

allaboutfish 08-21-2012 10:47 AM

What are the different care requirements between endlers and rams? So should I start with 6?
Posted via Mobile Device

Chesh 08-21-2012 11:10 AM

They're completely different animals, lol! They feed differently, swim differently, interact differently. . .

Do you know off-hand what the Gh of the water in this tank is?

Rams like their water soft and acidic, while Endler's prefer their water to be on the harder side of things. You may find it difficult to feed the rams in this setup without overfeeding the Endlers - assuming they're much like guppies and other live-bearers in their feeding habits - and either way, your beautiful Endlers would be uncomfortable in soft water, and your rams won't do very well if your water is hard. I'm not sure about Barbs, as I've never kept them.

If I were you I'd start with only one, and see how it goes - unless you are able to find a mated pair. You won't have the space to keep six in a tank that size - even if they play nice together - I think that there isn't enough room for them to choose territories, and overstocking can cause issues with tank parameters and rising nitrates, which the Rams may not tolerate. Then consider that re-homing them or separating them should they prove agressive toward one-another may be difficult. Its nearly impossible to sex a Bolivian Ram as a juvie, and if you happen to get all or mostly males, you may find yourself in a world of trouble! Generally, these fish are considered to be semi-aggressive, and in my experience, they tend to limit their aggression toward others of their kind - meaning that they won't go after other types of fish. With that said, they *can* be very nasty toward other Bolivians, even unto death at times. . . Even if you are able to find a mated pair, be sure to watch them very closely, as I have read of several incidents where even a mating pair decide, for whatever reason, to 'divorce' and it usually ends badly for one of them, if they are not removed from the tank. They can also be aggressive toward other speceis if they're actively guarding eggs, so something else to consider.

Bolivian Rams are my favorites, I don't want to scare you away from the possibility of keeping them - as I'm convinced that you'd find them to be as fascinating as I do - but do your research here. They tend to stress easily, and aren't as tough as some people make them out to be, surely not as tough as Endler's or Barbs. I personally don't consider them to be a 'mean' fish, mine live in perfect harmony with nothing more than 'friendly' displays of dominance now that they've figured out their pecking order and have established their territories. But I've seen some instances in other people's tanks where things got bad quickly, so you have to be prepared for the possibility, and ready to move should any bullying occur.

ETA: I currently have four - three females and one male - in a 29 gallon well planted soft-water tank with very low nitrates. I would not add any more to my tank, and there are some who would consider even this to be overstocked (I don't, but each tank is different). I also have a 20 gallon long, and if I was planning to stock rams in a tank this size, I'd put 3 at the MAX - but I've never done it, so this is just a guess based on my own limited experience with the species. If you DO choose to get more than one (and I must again recommend that you start with one, and only IF your water is right for them - just to see how he/she does in your community) I would say to make sure that there is only one male in the group - or even stick with all females. But again - this is really tough to tell when they're juvies, and only slightly easier as they reach adulthood.

allaboutfish 08-21-2012 03:34 PM

my ph is 7.8 but ive always heard that they will adjust with proper acclimatation. i keep german blue rams in the same water. i feed nls sinking pellets so it should be easier for the ram to get some food.

Byron 08-21-2012 03:58 PM

Some fish species can adjust to different water parameters, some cannot. Or it may be more correct to say that some fish will be healthy in varying water parameters whereas other species will not. For example, livebearers simply do not last in soft water, and Endlers are livebearers. They need the mineral (calcium and magnesium) in harder water.

Knowing your GH (general hardness) will be useful, along with the pH. You shold be able to get the hardness from the municipal water people.

In the initial post it mentions 9 cherry barb and 3 otos. If you do get a single ram (just one, they do fine in isolation) I wouldnot get more fish (Endlers, or anything else).

allaboutfish 08-21-2012 06:51 PM

i dont have the ottos yet. i was just thinking of getting them. anyway my ph is 7.8


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:18 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2