He looks pretty good to me. The color is awesome, not sure how it would be placed in a show but it looks amazing. Form wise there aren't many issues, but the anal gets that spike at the right end and is rounded on the left edge, so if he was to be bred you would want a female with a good anal. His topline isn't bad (HMPKs don't have to have the smooth topline HMs do, it can be rounded like his is). Overall one good looking fish.