Should I get a shrimp or snail? Or both?
Tropical Fish

Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources » Freshwater Fish and Aquariums » Freshwater and Tropical Fish » Should I get a shrimp or snail? Or both?

Should I get a shrimp or snail? Or both?

This is a discussion on Should I get a shrimp or snail? Or both? within the Freshwater and Tropical Fish forums, part of the Freshwater Fish and Aquariums category; --> Hey all, I'm slowly starting to get my tank in order. I've got an all planted tank now with driftwood for my clown pleco. ...

Check out these freshwater fish profiles
Lambchop Rasbora
Lambchop Rasbora
Filament Barb
Filament Barb
Reply
LinkBack Thread Tools vBmenu Seperating Image Search this Thread vBmenu Seperating Image
Should I get a shrimp or snail? Or both?
Old 06-10-2011, 07:23 AM   #1
 
Should I get a shrimp or snail? Or both?

Hey all,

I'm slowly starting to get my tank in order. I've got an all planted tank now with driftwood for my clown pleco. The other inhabitants are 3x emerald cory catfish, 5x black widow tetra, and 4x serpae tetra. I might be adding more of the tetras because I know they do better in higher numbers. I've noticed my java moss is not doing well and either has brown algae on it or it's dying (I can't really tell). The moss is about 4 weeks old. (More info is in profile.)

As for feeding, I feed the tetras flake (every night) and the occasional micro pellets (which I might return, they never seem to go for them; almost as if they can't see them. Unless I maybe get some top fish), occasional bloodworms, and algae wafers (every night). I try not to overfeed: I crumble some of the flake food in a cup of tank water and slowly add a little of that mix to the tank at a time (I saw this as a way to help the flake sink...any thoughts on if this is a good technique?) The reason I don't just add the flake where it floats at the top is because I think the BW crowd out the serpae--the serpae don't come up to grab it at the top, where if it sinks I see them actually eating it.

As for the wafers, I put 3 into the tank via a piece of pvc so I can angle it to their favorite areas. I try to do this a few minutes before or after lights go out for the night. (The other feeding is right before). Even though the tetras have been fed flake, they seem to wait around and find the wafers even if I add them after lights out, so hopefully my bottom feeders are getting enough. I occasionally get a somewhat cloudy tank, but not too often.

So with the feeding and the thing with my java moss, as well as maintaining the tank in general, should I consider getting a snail (for algae and/or food debris) and/or shrimp?
yodapoolman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-10-2011, 01:31 PM   #2
 
wshfail's Avatar
 
Sounds like you are feeding a lot. Do you notice if your fish have swollen belly's?

As for Shrimp or Snail my vote is for shrimp. They are way more entertaining and will eat everything from flakes to pellets to poop. If you are having issues with cloudiness id say slack off a little on the food maybe just tail off the wafers. I know all my fish seem to be so fixated on them that they eat until they are swollen so i need to break them in half.

One thing to note about a snail is that they have a lot of waste if you just wanting something to clean the glass you should look into a Chinese Algae Eater (Gyrinocheilus aymonieri). They will take care of the glass.
wshfail is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-10-2011, 03:08 PM   #3
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by wshfail View Post
Sounds like you are feeding a lot. Do you notice if your fish have swollen belly's?

As for Shrimp or Snail my vote is for shrimp. They are way more entertaining and will eat everything from flakes to pellets to poop. If you are having issues with cloudiness id say slack off a little on the food maybe just tail off the wafers. I know all my fish seem to be so fixated on them that they eat until they are swollen so i need to break them in half.

One thing to note about a snail is that they have a lot of waste if you just wanting something to clean the glass you should look into a Chinese Algae Eater (Gyrinocheilus aymonieri). They will take care of the glass.
Please note the profile for the chinese algae eater. You may not want it in your tank. Often controlling the amount of light getting to the tank will lessen the amount of algae growth.
brownmane is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-10-2011, 03:15 PM   #4
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by yodapoolman View Post
Hey all,

I've noticed my java moss is not doing well and either has brown algae on it or it's dying (I can't really tell). The moss is about 4 weeks old. (More info is in profile.)
Java moss is very slow growing and takes a while to attach to wherever you want it to grow. I had some and think that a lot of it was eventually sucked into the intake tube because I tried to hold it in place with gravel on top of driftwood and the gravel kept falling off. Much of the colouring was brown with very little green. Anyway there is a bit now growing onto the driftwood (the growth is green). So don't give up too soon. You might actually have live moss.
brownmane is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-11-2011, 09:24 AM   #5
 
Thank you for all the replies. The tank itself doesn't seem to have a lot of algae, I just couldn't identify what was up with my Java Moss, but I think Brownmane cleared it up for me.

I read the profile on the CAE and agree that it probably wouldn't be the best for my tank. One of the reasons I was considering a snail was because of the bits of leaves and stuff or pieces of the moss that have fallen to the bottom of the tank. I do water changes and try to get most of it, but sometimes just moving the hose around the plants breaks more off so there's more leaves on the bottom AFTER I do the wc lol.

Which shrimp would do well in this community tank with tetras, cories, and the pleco?
yodapoolman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-11-2011, 01:35 PM   #6
 
Byron's Avatar
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by yodapoolman View Post
Thank you for all the replies. The tank itself doesn't seem to have a lot of algae, I just couldn't identify what was up with my Java Moss, but I think Brownmane cleared it up for me.

I read the profile on the CAE and agree that it probably wouldn't be the best for my tank. One of the reasons I was considering a snail was because of the bits of leaves and stuff or pieces of the moss that have fallen to the bottom of the tank. I do water changes and try to get most of it, but sometimes just moving the hose around the plants breaks more off so there's more leaves on the bottom AFTER I do the wc lol.

Which shrimp would do well in this community tank with tetras, cories, and the pleco?
Shrimp are fine, but need to be large enough or they will be eaten. Freshwater crustaceans are a prime food source for all characins (tetra).

Snails are immensely helpful in aquaria. Not only do they eat stuff nothing else (including the shrimp) will, they eat some algae [not sufficient to rid a tank, but that is another matter], but primarily they are a major contributor to the health of the aquarium by breaking down larger organic substances into smaller bits that the bacteria xcan more readily handle. Especial;ly in the substrate, where Malaysian Livebearing snails are a miracle of sorts.

I would remove larger bits of plants that break off. While eventually this will not have much impact, at the beginning (before the tank is well established) it is best not to overload the system with organics.

During the water change, leave the substrate alone as you have plants.
Byron is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
10 gallon snail/shrimp tank xrayjeeper83 Freshwater Journals 4 06-13-2010 10:32 AM
Need help with Shrimp and Snail identification xDarkPassenger Invertebrates 4 02-10-2010 12:17 PM
tiny shrimp kit had snail and ?slug? acgaslover Invertebrates 6 03-26-2009 02:12 PM
snail or shrimp? ollecram Invertebrates 13 07-14-2008 06:44 PM


Tags
algae on moss, feeding, shrimp, snail

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:33 AM.