This is a discussion on Elephantnose fish (Gnathonemus petersii) within the Freshwater and Tropical Fish forums, part of the Freshwater Fish and Aquariums category; -->
Has anyone kept this fish? I saw one today at the LFS and fell in love with it but I don't know the minimal ...
Has anyone kept this fish? I saw one today at the LFS and fell in love with it but I don't know the minimal requirements for this fish? Like what is the smallest the tank can be? I have seen different answers for this so would y'all think a 55 gallon be to small for one?
One of my dream fish in a hardwater african set up.
Here's a good profile: Gnathonemus petersii (Elephantnose Fish) — Seriously Fish
55 gallons would be a tight squeeze, especially with other fish. If it's a really long/wide tank as opposed to high, that would be helpful. And more than one would be a no go.
Though it says they are unfussy I remember a member on another forum having loads of trouble feeding theirs. The poor fish went quite a without eating and faster fish were eating all it's food. I'm guessing this fish is usually wild caught and therefore a frozen/live diet is best. Also those mouths are adapted to eating things like small worms, not flakes. Posted via Mobile Device
Thanks Olympia, I have read that page you linked and others as well. I was thinking a 55 would be pushing it but thought I would ask and see others opinions. The only other tank I have that is wider is also shorter then the 55 and its a 40b. So I guess I would just have to wait till I get a bigger tank some day before I can keep this fish.
So now I royally confused. I know that one particular site says 255L (67gallons)is best but I have read many sites where people have then in a 55 gallon with no problem. Its really hard for me to go with just one site saying no when I have read many that say yes. Knowing the "No" site is more then likely right.
Is your 55 stocked with anything?
Try finding out more about it's activity level. They are nocturnal for one. But if at night they enjoy swimming around like crazy, I might feel bad denying it space. If they are slow movers it could be more doable. Posted via Mobile Device
Yeah Angelfish and Otos. The Angelfish are about to get rehomed I think as I been wanting bottom dwellers for awhile now but the Angels are so food aggressive that nothing else can get food. No matter if its flakes or sinking wafers the Angels go after it.
I love that fish. My wife has been on me to get one when we begin our new tank. I'm considering it. It's either that, or a Black Ghost Knife (not both obviously).
