Tropical Fish Keeping banner

Silver dollars

17K views 17 replies 8 participants last post by  northwindtucker 
#1 ·
what is the smallest tank a silver dollar can be housed in?

What is recommended?

I've read anywhere from a 20 to a 55. Just curious.
 
#3 ·
Silver dollars can get huge............the size of a small plate........6 inches round from what i seen........You should have a small shoal of at least 5 or 6, but with the potential size of the fish and the size of the shoal, i would say nothing smaller than a 6 foot tank............IMO, this is one fish that shouldnt be sold too much in the hobby world........They get big, need to be housed with their own kind (small shoal), and need a large tank, which alot of people dont realize till they have them home in there community tank.......Plus they are notoriously plant eaters
 
#4 ·
I've done some research but i always prefer getting more info from more knowledgeable people. Some of the suggestions online are just way off. I don't plan on having any plants in the tank with them, not real ones at least. I understand they can get upwards of 6 inches and need a shoal to be happy. I currently have a 55 gallon, is there any way you could house 5 or 6 happily in that or is it still too small?
 
#5 ·
As long as it's heavily filtered you should be ok. They are schooling fish, but they don't spend all day swimming back and forth like crazy (like something like a danio would) so they don't need huge amounts of swimming space. I would say a four foot tank would be a minimum (like your 55g). If you were ever to upgrade to a larger tank, shoals of silver dollars generally make pretty decent tankmates for medium to large American cichlids.
 
#7 ·
It could be possible, but you'd definitely want to over-filter the tank. Also, in such a tank you'd absolutely need a lot of tall, grassy fake plants made of silk. Silver dollars are like aquatic lawnmowers so you won't have any luck with live plants, but angels really like to have tall grassy plants to swim through.

If you are looking for a similar looking fish to silver dollars that stays a bit smaller and doesn't eat plants, Colombian tetras might be a good choice. They grow to about 2.5", so you should be able to keep a good sized school of them with angels in a planted tank with no problems.

If you do decide to try the silver dollars, be sure you're getting regular silver dollars and not "red hook" silver dollars as these grow much bigger (almost a foot!).
 
#8 ·
would two penguin 350's be enough filtration or is that still lacking some? Dually noted on the plants. I can take care of that.. in fact i already have it planned out in my head. OTher than those two things there should be enough room for all the fish to live happily?

I've always loved the silver dollars and would like to stick with them. If i can't make it happen in a 55 then i'll just hold off for a while. It's basically all or nothing at this point. I appreciate the suggestion greatly though. THanks for trying to help me find a simpler solution. I'm just set on the silver dollars, i love the way they look. Like i said if i can't make that happen right now in the 55 ill wait til later down the line wihen things line up and i can get a bigger tank.
 
#9 ·
^^anybody?

The plans have changed slightly. I will be doing just a shoal of silver dollars in the 55, without the angels. Do they care whether they have plants, etc? I plan on doing a shoal of cories as well if i can do that. dual penguin 350s if that is good enough.
 
#10 ·
^^anybody?

The plans have changed slightly. I will be doing just a shoal of silver dollars in the 55, without the angels. Do they care whether they have plants, etc? I plan on doing a shoal of cories as well if i can do that. dual penguin 350s if that is good enough.
Glad you've decided to forget the angels, these would not make good tankmates in my opinion. You should be OK with a shoal (minimum 5) of Metynnis argenteus [Silver Dollar] in a 4-foot 55g tank, although authorities like Seriously Fish agree with earlier posts in this thread that adult fish require a 6-foot tank. Corys in a shoal (6 or more) will be OK, as the SD prefer the middle to upper reaches of the aquarium. Vegetable diet is essential for the Silver Dollars, some floating live plants as a food source would be good; duckweed proliferates rapidly and is apparently a favoured food of Silver Dollars; floating fern (Ceratopteris) is also a quick grower, and being tender might be welcomed as part of the diet. You can find out more at Silver Dollar (Metynnis hypsauchen) - Seriously Fish and other sites.

The natural biotope of these fish in SA are thickly planted streams which is indicative of slower water currents; consequently, there should not be too strong a current from the filter. Not that I'm suggesting live plants (although that would be good as food) but it gives an indication that the fish do not prefer strong currents if it is not a feature of their natural environment. Good regular tank maintenance (weekly partial water change with vacuuming of the substrate) will be essential, and far more so than strong filtration. And larger fish in smaller tanks benefit more from more frequent water changes than more filtration which does nothing but move the water around. Water changes replace water with fresh, minerals, and removes nitrates.
 
#11 ·
Thanks for the info and link, very helpful. The angels are going in a new tank i will be getting. I definitely plan on feeding the SDs lots of vegetable matter, along with algae wafers and bloodworms and brine shrimp on occasion. I definitely do a weekly water change on all of my tanks as i believe strongly in maintaining a very healthy environment for all of my fish.

Will 6 cories, and 6 SD work well?

will different SD shoal together? Say 3 silvers, 3 spotted. or 4 silver, 2 spotted?
 
#12 ·
Thanks for the info and link, very helpful. The angels are going in a new tank i will be getting. I definitely plan on feeding the SDs lots of vegetable matter, along with algae wafers and bloodworms and brine shrimp on occasion. I definitely do a weekly water change on all of my tanks as i believe strongly in maintaining a very healthy environment for all of my fish.

Will 6 cories, and 6 SD work well?

will different SD shoal together? Say 3 silvers, 3 spotted. or 4 silver, 2 spotted?
Yes, six and six are OK now when they're young--just remember the SD will grow and require more space. And fish that attain a largish size as adult need adequate conditions to grow in or they can face internal problems (development, immune system issues, etc) arising from what is termed "stunting" which is probably due more to the water quality than the actual space; but space enters the equation because a smaller quantity of water will deterioriate more rapidly than a larger volume. If this doesn't make sense, ask and I'll explain further. For this reason I would recommend partial water changes of 40-50% weekly.

As for your last question, I have not personally kept this species (or more correctly, these species, since there are several similar in appearance and behaviour), but here's a link to one site that says they can be housed together. Silver Dollar | Metynnis argenteus You might want to do a Google search of this fish and check other sites. As others here will tell you, one can find differing information on the internet, so it is wise to check several authorities for consistent advice. This is something I have always done whenever I have considered acquiring SA fish that are new to me. I want to know exactly what I'm acquiring before I bring them home. It can save a lot of bother over unsuitable fish.

Byron.
 
#16 ·
Hey Yippee, Sorry I didn't see your post sooner. I had 3 or 4 silver dollars along with 3 or 4 angels and some other fish and they did quite well for a long time. The SD grew up big and the angels grew big too and even had eggs, pretty neet. I had a lot of filtration but not an over kill. I had 1- magnum 350, a UV light, and the larger whisper filter. I think that's all I had. I was not good with the water changes but they did real good even with a WC every 3 months. When I moved I gave them all to the LPS. Here is pics of my tank after I moved and repopulated it. I don't see the angels but I did have them, probably after this was taken. Well, I don't know how to upload the pics here, I'll try and upload them to my profile.
 
#18 ·
I have 3 redhooks and a spotted SD in my 55 (also a bushynose and a few corycats). When I bought my redhooks, the guy at the LFS gave me a spotted SD that had outgrown one of his customers tanks. He said that it needed a home and would do well with the redhooks. They swim together like they were all the same type of fish. At the time the spotted one was twice as big as the redhooks. In no time the red hooks were more than twice as big as the spotted. Four years later the red hooks are now 7-8 inches long. For filtration I have a penguin 350, emperor 280, and a hot mag 250. I have very hard water and and high ph. As long as I do a minimum 40% water change a week(preferably 20% twice a week), they do very well. Anything less(while I 'm on a long vacation) their fins split and get a little ragged. A few extra water changes and they are back to normal.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top