So, finally discovered last night why my anacharis has constantly been getting up-rooted, as well as where my neon tetras have been disappearing to.
After about an hour after turning off my light, I went back into my room to get something and saw my common pleco chasing a Neon Tetra, catch it in the anacharis, then continue to slowly munch on it.
It sucks, but there isn't much I can do about it now. Not sure why he would do this, they stay out of his cave, and he gets fed regularly, 2-4 algae wafers a day, plus the food he finds laying around.
Anyone else ever have an issue you like this? Again, doesnt bug me, just found it surprising, so I thought I would share it.