Tropical Fish Keeping banner

Play sand substrate????

2K views 5 replies 6 participants last post by  Byron 
#1 ·
Some people on this forum have said that play sand is a good cheap substrate for a tank. Is it really ok for a planted tank? should you do more than just rinse it? Are there any bad things in it? Sorry if this is a retorrical question just really want to know.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
#3 ·
Well play sand works fine for planted tanks except it compacts a bit. I think to combat this you can get malaysian trumpet snails or poke with a stick in the gravel every once in a while to loose it up.

It won't have the nutrients in the gravel like other substrates but I think if you get root tabs it would be fine. ^_^

You don't have to do anything except wash it really good. (It's a pain to wash).
 
#4 ·
I used playsand PLENTY times over & over for yrs now, I just buy it at Lowes, rinse it 2-3x in the yard and add it to my tank, never had issues. I do however use MT Snails in my sand tanks.
 
#6 ·
Depends what it is comprised of; some sands contain calcareous substances that will raise hardness and pH. Some may contain other substances or additives that hopefully would be stated on the bag. Of course it all contains dirt which has to be washed/rinsed out (very tedious;-)).

I would just caution on using white or light sand: it reflects light, and most fish come from habitats with dark substrates and many species actually feel insecure over a light substrate because it is, frankly, un-natural to them. I can get dark gray play sand here, and it looks fine; I'm intending to experiment with it in a 10g, but I have so far not managed to wash it sufficiently. I personally would never use white sand. Fish and plants also show much better colour over a dark substrate; in the case of plants it is aesthetic (just looks better), but with fish they are deliberately darkening their cell pigments naturally because it is their instinct, and their colours darken accordingly and sparkle and shine beautifully with a dark substrate and dark background.

Byron.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top