Hey guys! Just wondering if LED lighting is any good, cause I'm planning on getting a 29 gallon tank, 36" length, 10" width, and 16" height. I was looking at the marineland LED double bright aquarium lighting system, and was looking at either the 600 lumen rated one, or the 1200 lumen rated one. I do plan on having quite a few plants in the 29 gallon, mainly made up of wisteria, anacharis, anubias, java fern, and java moss. And maybe amazon sword. Thanks!
Good question. I was just trying to find out the same thing. I have a 20 gal planted aquarium with LED, since January, and the plants seem to being doing fine. They don't grow as quickly as they did when I had fluorescent bulbs for plant growth. I have val, java fern, java moss, several crypt wendtii, and something that is very similar to cabomba but I can't remember what it is called. My kit didn't even give me any type of light rating, so I don't know how to tell what I have.
extremely expensive, but otherwise its fine for plant growth. Im using them on my 6g and they're doing fine, im able to grow HC Cuba, but they were pricey.
I doubt its very good then. The number one thing determining the quality of an LED fixture is the type of LEDs. Most do not use the proper LEDs and emit very low light that is not plant friendly. A proper fixture requires 3 watt LED (no your normal kind at all), these run like $8-12 per LED. They also don't save much on power since you still that wattage. They require slightly less watts then a HO T5 bulb. So as SinCrisis said they can work, but are very expensive. Its cheapest to build them yourself, but they are still expensive.
LED lights are horrible, terrible, worthless, waste of money!
Before I made the mistake of buying an LED lamp to replace the 13W CF 6000k bulb my tank was lush and looked like this..
Before LED
Now it looks terrible, the plants are in such bad shape I am going to have to replace them all and replant my tank. LEDs'.. boo!
By the way that growth is less than a month apart from when I installed the LED into play. It cost $25 incl shipping off eBay. The stand is DIY made from spare IKEA parts for a curtain. Next week I am going to have to make the second trim in one month so LED = explosive growth. I don't care what anyone says about it, that light I am using is the s*.
I think the issue for your LED setup is that your LEDS are too high up, your losing a ton of light whereas your previous setup was directly over the tank so less light escaped.
Yes LED's are not aweful lots of people use them and have good results. They need to be done properly though or they will work just as well as any other improper light. I see many issues with your setup as already mentioned lights are too high. Then their is the issue of what kind of led's, what size, what wattage, color temp, ect.... their is no way that little fixture is equivalent to the 13 watts and intensity of the fluorescent. Regardless you lost a lot of light making the switch.
Well, from the sound of things LED lights are still iffy, so I'm going for some T5 HO lights. Just got a zoo med double light 36" light fixture, with 2 6250 rated lights *don't recall exact number, will post up later* rated for plant growth. Got it for 82 bucks free 2 day shipping off of amazon, so saved lots of money there. I love free amazon prime and if ure a student with a .edu email, you too can get free amazon prime for a year if you register your school email with your amazon account. Posted via Mobile Device
Good plant-friendly LEDs are available, but $$$$ (not yet cost-effective to my wallet). I have the same fixture you just purchased on my 55 gallon. I'm assuming it's an Aqua-sun? You'll have too much light with two T5HO bulbs unless you suspend it waaay above the tank. I recommend, from my experience, using only one bulb long-term unless you plan on using pressurized CO2 or want to grow really massive algae sheets.
What type of algae would grow? Maybe I am trying to grow algae for my future shrimp ._. muahahaha! But how high did you suspend yours? I currently cannot suspend mine as its kinda in the middle of nowhere in my room. Haha. I'll use 1 bulb for now, and see how things go.
My light is mounted using the plastic mounts that came with the unit (about 3-4" above the water). I dose with Excel into a tank that's planted pretty well. Even with the Excel dosing and using only one bulb I'll get algae if I leave the light on for more than 7-8 hours/day. When I first set up the tank, I had no algae issues initially and I was using both T5HO bulbs about 10 hours/day. Took a month before algae started to be a real problem. I started with the brown diatoms right after setting up the tank (normal, went away), and I then started getting lots of the green filamentous (hair) algae until I cut back on my light. Had to remove the hair algae using an old toothbrush every other day! Currently if I set my light timer for more than about 7hours/day, I get a flat, very bright green algae that starts making spots on my older plant leaves.
I have a canopy planned, a home-built, that will elevate my light about 6 more inches and I'll then use some fiberglass window screen to further reduce the light so I can use both bulbs (better color balance). FYI, each layer of screen reduces the light about 40%, if you ever need to use it.
I'd love to add some shrimp to my tank to eat the algae and just because they are neat. Unfortunately, my angelfish would really "love" them too - as a snack
By screen do you mean fiberglass screen? Or just any screen? Currently my light has a acrylic splash guard, and then my tank has a acrylic cover. The light is 2-3 inches from the top of the tank. I'll see if I can get some things to prop it up to get it 4-5 inches up. But just wondering if my 2 acrylic sheets mentioned would act as a screen. Thanks!
I think the acrylic will block any UV from the lights, but the fiberglass/plastic window screen material (could use aluminum screen, I suppose) acts like a shade cloth, physically blocking the other light wavelengths. You could always just lay a layer of screen onto the acrylic tank cover between the light and the water. That would reduce it, but still not enough if you use both T5HO tubes at once without raising the fixture. The current planted tank "consensus" from my readings seems to be moving to less light (light as the limiting factor) to reduce the issues of algae and, to some extent, make it easier on the fish - who generally don't appreciate super-bright lights.
Be very careful propping up your light fixture, if you do that, make certain it's solid. One good bump, it's in the tank, and you could get quite a shock :-(, as well as ruin the fixture!
The environmental downside of running two bulbs, just for color balance, is it takes twice as much electricity...
Just run one bulb if 2 bulbs is too much light. Color temps main effect is personal preference of how the light looks.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Tropical Fish Keeping
597.8K posts
83.7K members
Since 2006
forum community dedicated to tropical fish owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about species,breeding, health, behavior, aquariums, adopting, care, classifieds, and more! Open to fish, plants and reptiles living in freshwater or saltwater environments.