Eco Complete vs ?
Tropical Fish

Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources » Freshwater Fish and Aquariums » Beginner Freshwater Aquarium » Beginner Planted Aquarium » Eco Complete vs ?

Eco Complete vs ?

This is a discussion on Eco Complete vs ? within the Beginner Planted Aquarium forums, part of the Beginner Freshwater Aquarium category; --> I think I"m going to redo my NPT this weekend and go with something a bit easier. By easier I mean "Oh that plant ...

Like Tree2Likes

Reply
Old 02-14-2013, 12:28 AM   #1
 
Aurie's Avatar
 
Eco Complete vs ?

I think I"m going to redo my NPT this weekend and go with something a bit easier. By easier I mean "Oh that plant is huge, I need to remove it.." slow... slow pull.. BAM soil everywhere! GRRR I just can't stand it and all I wanted to do was pull a dwarf sag that was huge and sending babies everywhere. I decided it wasn't the plant for my tank.

I want to put something in the tank that can sit by itself without a topper. I have access to most of the major brands but I like the look of Eco Complete the most by looking at people's aquascapes.

I have a question though for those of you who use it by itself:

If you move a plant does it "poof" up. If I use a plant with runners and trim the runners and I don't want a cloud where I pulled it up from.

The problem I have is that the bags of this stuff are huge and I need about half of it. Isn't there water in the bag? if I don't use it all should I store it in a specific way?

I don't want to go over $20 for my substrate.. $10 would be best but I realise that isn't gonna happen.


Thanks for answering
Aurie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-14-2013, 04:41 AM   #2
 
fish monger's Avatar
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aurie View Post
I think I"m going to redo my NPT this weekend and go with something a bit easier. By easier I mean "Oh that plant is huge, I need to remove it.." slow... slow pull.. BAM soil everywhere! GRRR I just can't stand it and all I wanted to do was pull a dwarf sag that was huge and sending babies everywhere. I decided it wasn't the plant for my tank.

I want to put something in the tank that can sit by itself without a topper. I have access to most of the major brands but I like the look of Eco Complete the most by looking at people's aquascapes.

I have a question though for those of you who use it by itself:

If you move a plant does it "poof" up. If I use a plant with runners and trim the runners and I don't want a cloud where I pulled it up from.

The problem I have is that the bags of this stuff are huge and I need about half of it. Isn't there water in the bag? if I don't use it all should I store it in a specific way?

I don't want to go over $20 for my substrate.. $10 would be best but I realise that isn't gonna happen.


Thanks for answering
Well, you probably won't get the color you want but, I and many others have had great luck with play sand. A 50 lb. bag of Quikrete Play Sand goes for under $4.00 at The Home Depot. You need to rinse it very thoroughly and your water might be cloudy for a day or two...less if you clean well. Plants that I had always had trouble growing do very well in it. You'll probably need to use more fertilizers with it than with a soil substrate but, from what I've read on the site, the so-called planted tank substrates have little advantage over standard aquarium gravel.
fish monger is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-14-2013, 04:47 AM   #3
 
Aurie's Avatar
 
I have about 47 lbs of pool filter sand that I can use lol. I like sand OK but I like the look of the Eco and wanted to give it a try
Posted via Mobile Device
Aurie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-14-2013, 05:03 AM   #4
 
fish monger's Avatar
 
I can certainly understand how you feel. The additional ferts will probably still be necessary to get the growth you're experiencing now. Best of luck !
fish monger is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-14-2013, 05:07 AM   #5
 
Aurie's Avatar
 
I think going NPT on a 5.5 was a bit of a jump for me. it's too much to take in. Things are growing so fast I can't trim or rip out runners. It's not tall enough for many stem plants and it feels crowded. I am also a fert newb. Completely! I once put a couple drops of excel into my 10 gallon and all of a sudden my 2 year old java fern lost 90% of its leaves. They just melted away. I'm still mad about it since I had just given away 90% of my ferns to a LFS and kept the ones I wanted. I only did a NPT so I wouldn't have to do so many water changes on the tank but I think it's just better to replant it and rescape it into something easier.


BTW this is the tank in question
the sags on the left are the ones I ripped out. My fish kept getting caught in them

MMAfish35 likes this.
Aurie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-14-2013, 05:40 AM   #6
 
fish monger's Avatar
 
That tank is beautiful. I wouldn't touch a thing but, that's just me. The best fert I've found is Seachem Flourish Comprehensive. It's an all purpose balanced product. I've heard about problems with Excel and I think that it is because it is a very specific fert that is meant to be used in conjunction with other formulas. Used by itself, it can overdo in some areas. Keep in mind that there are folks who would kill to be in your position with having to thin their plants. Holding them back is never good. Perhaps you could just look into getting some slower growth rate plants. They would flourish in your substrate without over running your tank.
fish monger is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-14-2013, 11:03 AM   #7
 
Byron's Avatar
 
I don't know what fish you have, but with Eco-Complete (or Flourite, a near-identical product) substrate fish can have problems. Corys, pleco, loaches can be damaged by the roughness of these products. I speak from experience.

Second point is that I have not found these two products made any difference in plant growth, so they are in my view a waste of money. Last week I tore down my 70g that had been running for just under 2 years with Flourite. Now has play sand, much better. And I can have corys again.

Once you get good plant growth and have bits of wood, etc, the substrate becomes less "obvious." One other thing about black substrates, they show every speck of detritus, something I never see with the sand or gravel that are mixes.

Byron.
MMAfish35 likes this.
Byron is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-14-2013, 10:19 PM   #8
 
Aurie's Avatar
 
I don't mind the black specs of the soil here and there, what I mind is when I want to move a plant that is taking over my tank it doesn't spew soil everywhere pretty much making the layering useless. I sprinkled more sand over the area and I'm hoping for the best but I'm no so sure.

I think I just need different plants. The ones I have in there aren't what I'm looking for and the stores around me just have the generic "beginner" plants like java fern and anubias etc .. Maybe I should just do the whole thing in Mini Pellia and call it a day LOL

All that's in there is 1 betta, a nerite and a handful of MTS


Do you think if I switched to sand, and dosed about 1/4th to 1/2 mil of comprehensive 2x a week I'd be ok? I can't commit to dosing every day, and I'm not a chemist but it'd give me the ease of use that I'd be looking for so I could move things around if I needed to..

Last edited by Aurie; 02-14-2013 at 10:28 PM..
Aurie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-15-2013, 11:19 AM   #9
 
Byron's Avatar
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aurie View Post
I don't mind the black specs of the soil here and there, what I mind is when I want to move a plant that is taking over my tank it doesn't spew soil everywhere pretty much making the layering useless. I sprinkled more sand over the area and I'm hoping for the best but I'm no so sure.

I think I just need different plants. The ones I have in there aren't what I'm looking for and the stores around me just have the generic "beginner" plants like java fern and anubias etc .. Maybe I should just do the whole thing in Mini Pellia and call it a day LOL

All that's in there is 1 betta, a nerite and a handful of MTS


Do you think if I switched to sand, and dosed about 1/4th to 1/2 mil of comprehensive 2x a week I'd be ok? I can't commit to dosing every day, and I'm not a chemist but it'd give me the ease of use that I'd be looking for so I could move things around if I needed to..
I don't use soil in any of my tanks. I have plain sand or fine gravel substrates. I dose Flourish Comprehensive twice weekly, but I have very soft water and need this; sometimes once a week is sufficient. I use substrate tabs only for the larger swords in my big tanks.

Stem plants need reguar trimming, which usually means pulling them up, cutting off the tops and replanting those. I can see how a soil substrate would be a mess. Another option with the soil would be plants that don't need this, say crypts, or pygmy chain sword. Floating plants are essential for Betta and any anabantid.

Byron.
Byron is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-15-2013, 12:01 PM   #10
 
Stems IMO are not actually much of an issue in soil byron. They don't really root. It the crypts, swords, ect that root heavy that are a huge pain. You don't have to remove one often but when you do it makes a huge mess. Soil is quite different then other substrates in how very strongly plants can root in it. Removing a medium to large crypt your likely to tear half the roots in the process and pull up soil. I've occasionally killed larger crypts in my 15 gallon soil tank as its easier then trying to remove them. TBH if you don't get a very firm grip on the base of the rosette, the plant its liable to snap in half regardless.

As far as 'plant substrates' depends on looks and ease of use. It is certainly much much easier to dig up plants in eco-complete and flourite, so I like them alot in propagation tanks. I've yet to really try plain sand completely alone as I'm a bit skeptical on how much extra fertilizer I would have to dose. The gravels are easier if you have to move a tank IMO. I've moved my 55 twice in the last 2 years and its simple enough to pull up all the plants and just give the substrate a gravel vac before scooping it into buckets. My current fluorite is about 7 years old and my eco complete is 5-6 years old.
Mikaila31 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Eco complete CinBos Beginner Planted Aquarium 13 11-03-2012 05:16 PM
how much eco-complete for a 50g fighttest Beginner Freshwater Aquarium 3 07-30-2009 01:11 PM
Eco-complete ok or no? SheyFirestar Beginner Planted Aquarium 10 07-22-2008 11:35 PM
Eco Complete Busgod Beginner Freshwater Aquarium 6 03-23-2008 01:56 PM


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:16 PM.