lumens per square inch - Tropical Fish Keeping - Aquarium fish care and resources
Old 04-19-2008, 10:29 PM Thread Starter
New Member

lumens per square inch

Need someone who is smarter then I am to tell me if this is right:

I have a 55 gal corner tank It's radius is 27.5 inches by my calculations I have roughly 596 square inches of surface area.

i got this by this method( been forever since I was in school )

27.5 X 27.5 X 3.15159 = 2383.3899375 / 4 = 595.847484375

os here goes

596 X 22.43 / 79.4 = 168 watts of compact flourescent 6700k to 10000k
for very high light

I think I got it right (please corect me if I'm wrong )

"Of all the things I lost in life I miss my mind the most"

Work in progress what do you think so far:
http://www.busgod.com/Tropical%20Aqu...h%20Forum.html
Busgod is offline

Old 04-19-2008, 10:47 PM
Member

Umm, I'm absolute crap with that kinda stuff. However, fish2all posted this link in another thread recently, and I found it extremely helpful. It calculates how much light you truly have based on your tank size, watts and the TYPE of light (ei T-5, compact florescent, etc).

http://woo.gotdns.com/Aquarium/Lighting.htm
okiemavis is offline
Old 04-19-2008, 10:53 PM Thread Starter
New Member

thanks mavis I got the lumens per watt from there just not sure that the math is right :D

"Of all the things I lost in life I miss my mind the most"

Work in progress what do you think so far:
http://www.busgod.com/Tropical%20Aqu...h%20Forum.html
Busgod is offline

Old 04-20-2008, 01:40 AM
Banned

Lumens per watt is just a number to tell you the efficiency of your bulb and has no bearing on how much light.

I am currently trying to do a chart that will do away away with the watt per gallon myth. But I failed to take into consideration the number of bulbs on the market and getting technical data from manufacturers is a slow and tedious process.

At present, I have over 500 pages of technical data and sheets to process. That is on top of the calculations for each item at different specific depths of common aquariums. And I thought that I'd be done in two weeks, it's been almost 2 months now. lol

Lumens and spectral composition are the primary components in selecting a good bulb. Kelvins will also figure in to the equation, but not to the degree as lumens and spectrum. The primary concern is footcandles, the amount of light that reaches the plant, or work plane. All material has a light conductive coefficient. Water diffracts light and creates havoc when doing calculations. The deeper the tank, the more diffraction.

Don't mess with wattage unless you want to know the efficiency of the bulb.
herefishy is offline
Old 04-20-2008, 02:19 AM Thread Starter
New Member

thanks herefishy I understand that there are all kinds of factors in lighting tank.

just looking to find out if i have the general idea right, as to the formula.

"Of all the things I lost in life I miss my mind the most"

Work in progress what do you think so far:
http://www.busgod.com/Tropical%20Aqu...h%20Forum.html
Busgod is offline
Old 04-20-2008, 03:17 AM
Banned

Foot candles equation: Fc=Cp/(DxD)

Fc=footcandles

Cp=candlepower of the bulb

D=distance of the work plane from the lamp

Remember that the one factor not present is spectrum. Proper spectrum is also needed for planted tanks.
herefishy is offline
Old 04-23-2008, 05:37 PM
New Member

Busgod, your calculations start off in error. If you want to calculate area of a circle, it is simply Pi X (radius)^2. For some reason, you then divided this by four. Your area is actually the interim value of 2,384 square inches (actually you value for Pi was wrong - it's 3.14159, yielding 2,376 square inches, but who's counting?...)

Not sure what other logic you're using to calculate necessary lumens or watts required, but I think this answers your original question.
Old 04-23-2008, 06:29 PM
Banned

roadracr, he's working with a corner tank not a cylinder. A corner tank is 1/4 of a cricle.
herefishy is offline
Old 04-23-2008, 09:12 PM Thread Starter
New Member

thanks roadracer & herefishy and yes Its a corner tank not a circle.

so actually

27.5 X 27.5 X 3.14159= 2375.8274375 / 4 = 594

594 X 22.43 / 79.4 = 168

:D :D :D

"Of all the things I lost in life I miss my mind the most"

Work in progress what do you think so far:
http://www.busgod.com/Tropical%20Aqu...h%20Forum.html
Busgod is offline